If you’re considering buying gold or silver for the first time, one of the first questions you’ll face is where to buy it. Canada has a growing number of options — local coin shops and pawn shops with display cases of bullion, big bank programs, and online dealers like us. Each has genuine advantages, and the right choice depends on what matters most to you: price, selection, convenience, ongoing support, or a combination of all four.
We think the honest answer is that local coin shops serve a real purpose in the precious metals ecosystem. But there are also meaningful differences in how we operate, what we offer, and what that means for buyers — especially those building a serious position in physical gold and silver. This guide breaks it all down so you can make the most informed decision possible, whether you end up buying from us or somewhere else.
A Quick Overview of Both Options
Before getting into the details, it helps to understand what each type of dealer actually is and what they’re optimized for.
Local coin shops are brick-and-mortar retail businesses, typically owner-operated, that buy and sell coins, bullion, collectibles, and sometimes currency or jewellery. They’ve been a fixture in Canadian cities for decades and serve a mix of collectors, investors, and casual sellers. Their strength is in-person service and the ability to physically handle products before purchasing. Their limitations are typically inventory depth, pricing transparency, and the geographic constraint of needing to be nearby.
CanAm Bullion is a dedicated online precious metals dealer founded in Windsor, Ontario in 2017 by Michael Piccioni, an economist with 20+ years of experience at a Fortune 500 company. We operate across six locations in four countries, carry over $150 million in customer deposits, and ship fully insured to customers across Canada and the United States. Our focus is on investment-grade bullion — gold, silver, platinum, palladium, and Goldbacks — with transparent pricing tied directly to live spot prices.
| Factor | Local Coin Shop | CanAm Bullion |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Physical storefront — must be local | Online + Windsor location — ships Canada & US |
| Pricing transparency | Varies widely — often negotiated | Live spot-based pricing, visible online |
| Product selection | Limited by shelf space and turnover | Full range: bars, coins, silver, platinum, Goldbacks |
| Shipping | Typically in-store pickup only | Fully insured delivery within 1–3 business days |
| Storage solutions | Rarely offered | Vault storage in Vancouver, Toronto, and Calgary |
| Buyback program | Ad hoc — prices vary by day and owner | Structured buyback at competitive prices |
| Investment guidance | Depends on the individual owner | Dedicated specialist team, education-first approach |
| Available 24/7 | No — limited retail hours | Yes — online store always open |
1. Pricing: Spot-Based vs. Negotiated
This is where the difference is most tangible, and it affects every single transaction.
Our pricing is tied directly to the live gold and silver spot price, updated in real time on our website. When you browse our store, you see exactly what you’ll pay — the product price, the premium over spot, and the total before checkout. There’s no haggling, no day-to-day inconsistency, and no wondering whether the person at the counter gave the person before you a better deal.
Local coin shops operate differently. Many set prices based on their own cost of acquisition, current inventory, and what the market will bear that day. Some are very fair; others carry wide spreads between their buy and sell prices. The premium you pay at a local shop for a standard 1 oz gold bar can vary by hundreds of dollars depending on the shop’s overhead, their inventory age, and simply who’s behind the counter. For buyers making a one-time casual purchase, this may not matter. For anyone building a meaningful position — buying regularly or in larger quantities — the cumulative effect of pricing inconsistency adds up fast.
- Our premiums are competitive and published openly — no surprises at checkout
- Bulk purchases receive volume pricing, which local shops rarely offer consistently
- Paying by bank wire eliminates any credit card processing fee, further reducing your cost per ounce
2. Product Selection: Depth and Availability
A typical local coin shop carries whatever happens to be in their display case on the day you walk in. That might be a tray of silver maples, a few gold bars, and some numismatic coins — or it might be whatever came in from their last buyback. Inventory is driven by what customers have sold to them, not by a curated purchasing strategy designed around investor needs.
We carry a purpose-built inventory of investment-grade bullion across every major category:
- Gold: Bars from 1 gram to 1 kilogram from Valcambi, PAMP Suisse, Royal Canadian Mint, Perth Mint, Credit Suisse, and Rand Refinery
- Silver: Coins, bars, and rounds from the RCM, US Mint, Perth Mint, and leading private refiners
- Platinum and palladium: Coins and bars for investors diversifying beyond gold and silver
- Goldbacks: The full range of active state series — Utah, Nevada, New Hampshire, Wyoming, and Florida — making us one of the only reliable sources for Goldbacks in Canada
If you want a specific product — say, a 10 oz silver bar from a particular refiner, or a full 5-denomination Goldback set, or a 100 gram gold bar — we either have it or can source it. That kind of certainty is difficult to replicate at a local shop whose inventory is whatever came through the door last week.
3. Convenience: Shop on Your Schedule, Not Theirs
Local coin shops keep retail hours. Many are closed on weekends, most are closed by 5 or 6 pm on weekdays, and some are only open a few days a week. If you work regular business hours, actually visiting a coin shop requires taking time out of your day — and then hoping they have what you’re looking for when you get there.
Our store is open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. You can browse, compare products, research spot prices, and complete a purchase at 11pm on a Sunday in your living room. Orders are processed and shipped within 1–2 business days, with delivery across Canada and the United States in 1–3 business days on average. Every shipment is fully insured from the moment it leaves our facility until you sign for it at your door.
For buyers outside major urban centres — and a significant portion of our customers are in smaller cities, rural areas, and communities where quality coin shops simply don’t exist — online purchasing isn’t just more convenient. It’s the only realistic way to access investment-grade bullion at competitive prices.
4. Insured Shipping and Secure Storage
Local coin shops solve the “how do I get my gold home safely” question simply by handing it to you across the counter. That’s actually a legitimate advantage — there’s no shipping involved, no transit risk, no waiting. If you value that immediate physical handoff, a local shop delivers it.
What they almost never offer is what comes after: professional, insured vault storage for customers who don’t want to keep their metals at home. We do. Our storage facilities in Vancouver, Toronto, and Calgary hold over $150 million in customer deposits, with full insurance coverage and zero counterparty risk. Customers can choose to have their purchases shipped directly to their home or redirected to secure vault storage — a level of post-purchase infrastructure that no local coin shop operates.
| Storage / Delivery Option | Local Coin Shop | CanAm Bullion |
|---|---|---|
| In-person pickup | Yes | Yes — Windsor location |
| Insured home delivery | Rarely | Yes — Canada & US, 1–3 business days |
| Professional vault storage | No | Yes — Vancouver, Toronto, Calgary |
| Storage insurance | N/A | Yes — fully insured customer deposits |
5. Buying and Selling: The Buyback Question
One thing buyers often overlook until it’s too late is the sell side of the equation. When you’re ready to liquidate — whether that’s in two years or twenty — where you sell matters as much as where you buy.
Local coin shops do buy bullion, but their offers are typically lower than you’d expect. They need to make a margin on resale, their cash position varies day to day, and there’s no formal price discovery mechanism. Some shops are fair; others will offer significantly below spot, particularly on silver.
We maintain a structured buyback program at competitive market prices for products purchased through us, with a transparent process and no ambiguity about what you’ll receive. Our buy prices are tied to live spot rates in the same way our sell prices are. When you buy from a dealer with a clear, accountable buyback policy, you’re not just purchasing gold — you’re establishing a relationship with a counterparty you can return to when it’s time to sell.
6. Education and Ongoing Support
The best local coin shop owners are genuinely knowledgeable — many have decades of experience in numismatics and precious metals and can tell you things about a specific coin or bar that you won’t find in any database. That expertise is real and worth something, particularly for collectors interested in the numismatic side of the market.
Our expertise is focused specifically on investment-grade bullion and the financial context around it. CanAm Bullion was founded by Michael Piccioni, an economist with over two decades of experience at a Fortune 500 company, with a deliberate mission to make precious metals education accessible to everyday Canadians. Our specialist team guides first-time buyers through every step of the purchase process, answers questions about tax implications, storage options, and portfolio strategy, and publishes regular market analysis and educational content through our blog.
We’re not here to sell you something and send you on your way. We’re here to make sure you understand what you’re buying, why it fits your goals, and how to manage it effectively over time. That education-first approach is reflected in the fact that a significant portion of our customers are repeat buyers who’ve been with us since our early days.
When a Local Coin Shop Makes Sense
We want to be honest: there are situations where a local coin shop is the right choice, and we’d rather tell you that than pretend otherwise.
- You want to handle the product before buying. There’s something irreplaceable about holding a gold bar in your hand for the first time. If that tactile experience matters to you, a local shop provides it in a way no online photo can.
- You need cash immediately for a same-day sale. If you’re liquidating bullion and need cash in hand today, a local shop that does on-the-spot purchases can deliver that. Our buyback process, while competitive and transparent, involves shipping and a processing window.
- You’re primarily interested in numismatics or rare coins. Investment-grade bullion is our specialty. For rare numismatic coins, vintage currency, or highly specialized collectibles, a dedicated coin dealer with deep catalogue expertise may serve you better.
Why Most Serious Investors Choose an Online Bullion Dealer
The growth of online bullion dealing over the past decade reflects a simple reality: for investors focused on accumulating physical gold and silver at the best possible price, with the most product choice, the most flexibility, and the most professional post-purchase infrastructure, online dealers deliver consistently better outcomes than local retail shops.
That’s not a knock on local shops — it’s just how the economics work. We don’t pay downtown retail rent. We don’t have the overhead of a walk-in showroom. Those savings translate directly into tighter premiums, a deeper product catalogue, and the resources to build storage infrastructure, invest in technology, and grow a specialist team dedicated solely to precious metals.
If you’re ready to explore what we offer, browse our gold bars, Canadian Silver Maples, and Goldbacks — or call our team directly at 1-877-513-9399. We’re happy to answer questions, walk you through your first purchase, or just help you figure out what makes sense for your goals. No pressure, no upsell — just straight answers from people who know precious metals.
And if you’d like to learn more about who we are and what drives our approach, our About Us page gives you the full picture.
CEO and Founder of CanAm Bullion has been dedicated to delivering exceptional value to Canadians since 2017. Driven by a mission to empower Canadians with expert investment advice and education, he has positioned CanAm Bullion as a trusted resource for those seeking to enhance their portfolios with precious metals. Under Michael’s leadership, the company has become synonymous with reliability, knowledge, and dedication, helping Canadians achieve greater financial stability and long-term success.
Share This Article
Choose Your Platform: Facebook Twitter Google Plus Linkedin